The Witch's Eye
Simon and Schuster 2003
Great fit for 5th grade
Reading level and content both target 4th–8th grade · ages 9–14
Bookshop.org supports independent bookstores. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Retailer links may be affiliate links.
Genre
Themes
- friendship
- courage
- good vs. evil
- trust and deception
- sisters and family
- fear
- small-town secrets
- standing up to danger
About this book
In this fourth book of Phyllis Reynolds Naylor’s chilling Witch series, Lynn and Mouse sense that the frightening Mrs. Tuggle’s influence isn’t gone—and the girls must find the courage to face what still lurks in the shadows. Strange events and uneasy secrets test their friendship and their trust in the adults around them. Fast-paced and eerie without being too graphic, it’s a gripping read for middle graders who like supernatural suspense. Fans return for the relatable heroines, escalating tension, and the small-town mystery that keeps pages turning.
Setting: a small Midwestern town, contemporary
Readers also enjoyed
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Witch's Eye right for my child?
Yes — The Witch's Eye is a great fit for 5th grade. The reading level is AR 5.2, which is typical for 5th grade. The interest level is rated Middle Grades (4–8), meaning the themes and content are designed for ages 9–14 (4th–8th grade). Themes include friendship, courage, good vs. evil.
How long does it take to read The Witch's Eye?
At a typical 5th grade reading pace, The Witch's Eye takes around 5.0h to finish. The book has 49,000 words. Slower or faster readers may vary significantly.
Does The Witch's Eye have an AR quiz?
Yes — The Witch's Eye has an AR quiz available, worth 7 points. Your child will need to take and pass the quiz through their school's Accelerated Reader program to earn credit. The quiz is typically 5–20 multiple choice questions about plot, characters, and setting.
What grade level is The Witch's Eye?
The Witch's Eye has an AR reading level of 5.2, which places it at a 5th grade reading difficulty. The interest level is rated Middle Grades (4–8) — this reflects the age-appropriateness of the content and themes, not just the reading difficulty. A strong younger reader may handle the words fine while the themes are aimed at an older audience, or vice versa.